Can You Use Normal Soil in Aquarium? Is It Safe?

Smartplantedaquarium.com participates in affiliate marketing programs. We may earn commissions on purchases made through our affiliate links. This doesn't affect our content or recommendations and we only recommend products we would put in our own tanks.

Aquarium enthusiasts often find themselves engaged in debates and discussions regarding the use of various substrates in their aquatic environments. One question that frequently arises is whether it’s advisable to use normal soil, the type found in gardens and landscapes, as a substrate in aquariums.

This query holds significant importance for aquarists, as the choice of substrate plays a vital role in maintaining a healthy and thriving aquatic ecosystem.

Aquarium substrates serve as the foundation for aquatic life, influencing water chemistry, plant growth, and the overall well-being of fish and other inhabitants. While there are specialized substrates available in the market, the idea of using regular garden soil as a substrate raises intriguing possibilities.

In this article, we will delve into the debate surrounding the use of normal soil in aquariums, exploring the pros, cons, and considerations associated with this practice.

Key Takeaways

• Normal soil can be used in aquariums, but there are important considerations to take into account.
• Normal soil is widely available and cost-effective compared to specialized aquarium substrates.
• It is nutrient-rich and supports microbial diversity, which can benefit aquatic plants.
• However, normal soil can negatively impact water quality, pH, and hardness levels.
• It may contain harmful impurities and require careful preparation to avoid cloudiness and maintain water clarity.
• Regular soil can be difficult to maintain and may not be suitable for certain fish species or saltwater tanks.
• The use of commercial aquarium soil is specifically designed for aquatic plants and can help maintain water parameters and promote healthy root development.
• Making regular soil usable for aquariums involves selecting organic soil, sifting and cleaning it, sterilizing it, layering it in the tank, and slowly adding water.
• It is important to monitor water parameters, release any gas pockets, and be prepared for initial cloudiness.

Can You Use Normal Soil in Aquarium

Using regular garden soil or topsoil in aquariums can seem like an attractive option for many aquarium enthusiasts due to its easy availability and low cost. So yes, you can use normal soil in aquarium, but there are some things you need to do to make sure it is safe for your fish and plants.

It is safer and more beneficial to use aquarium-specific soil like Amazonia aqua soil or consider other substrate options that are designed to meet the specific needs of aquatic plants and fish.

However, before you make any decisions, it’s crucial to weigh up the pros and cons and make an informed choice based on your unique circumstances.

Pros of Using Normal Soil

Availability

Normal soil is a substrate that is widely used in aquatic gardening due to its easy accessibility. It can be found in gardens, yards, and other outdoor spaces, making it a cost-effective and convenient option for aquarists and aquatic gardeners alike. With its availability and versatility, normal soil has become a popular choice among those who are interested in creating a thriving aquatic environment.

Cost-effective

Normal soil is a cost-effective option compared to other substrates, such as commercial or specialized aquatic plant soils, making it an excellent choice for those looking to grow aquatic plants without breaking the bank. With its affordability, you can still achieve your desired results without sacrificing quality or variety.

Nutrient-rich

Normal soil serves as a natural reservoir of vital nutrients required by aquatic plants for their nourishment and development. It is home to an array of essential nutrients such as nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium that are indispensable for the robust growth of aquatic vegetation. Furthermore, normal soil also harbors organic matter that acts as a supplementary source of nutrients, enhances the soil structure, and contributes to the overall health of aquatic plants.

Microbial diversity

Normal soil is a bustling community of diverse microorganisms such as bacteria, fungi, and protozoa. These tiny creatures play a pivotal role in promoting the growth and vitality of aquatic plants by decomposing organic matter, releasing essential nutrients, and maintaining a thriving soil ecosystem.

Versatility

Normal soil is a versatile substrate that can be utilized in a range of aquatic gardening setups, whether you have a small aquarium or a large pond. You can use it on its own or combine it with other substrates, such as sand or gravel, to meet the specific needs of your aquatic plants. The possibilities are endless when it comes to creating the perfect underwater environment for your plants.

Long-lasting

Normal soil is a substrate that can provide aquatic plants with nutrients for an extended period of time. However, it’s important to keep an eye on nutrient levels and supplement them as necessary. By doing so, you can ensure that your plants receive the necessary nutrients to thrive. Remember, while soil is a valuable resource, it requires careful management to maintain its effectiveness.

Cons of Using Normal Soil

Water Quality

Normal soil used in an aquatic environment can release nutrients, including nitrogen and phosphorus, into the water. This excess nutrient supply promotes the growth of algae and other aquatic plants, leading to eutrophication. This, in turn, reduces oxygen levels in the water, resulting in the death of aquatic life. Additionally, soil erosion caused by water movement can lead to sedimentation and further degrade water quality.

pH and Hardness

The pH and hardness of water are crucial elements for various aquatic flora and fauna. The regular soil can have an impact on these factors, rendering the water unfavorable for particular species. For instance, some fish species necessitate a particular pH range for their optimal health and reproduction. If the water’s pH lies outside this range, it can lead to stress or, worse yet, the death of these fish. Similarly, certain aquatic plants require precise water hardness levels to flourish, and using regular soil can modify this equilibrium.

Soil Composition

Normal soil can be a source of harmful impurities, such as pesticides or fertilizers, that can adversely affect aquatic life. These chemicals can enter the water and accumulate in aquatic organisms, leading to serious health issues and even mortality. Additionally, normal soil may also contain heavy metals, like lead or cadmium, which can be harmful to aquatic life even in small amounts. These contaminants can enter the food chain, accumulate in larger animals, and cause long-term health problems and decreased population sizes. As such, it is critical to be mindful of the potential hazards that can arise from normal soil and take steps to mitigate them.

Messy

Using regular soil as a substrate in your aquarium may cause quite a mess. If the soil isn’t prepared correctly, it could make the water in your aquarium cloudy, which is not only unsightly but also stressful for your fish. Moreover, soil may contain hazardous bacteria and parasites that can cause harm to your fish. These microorganisms may enter your aquarium through the soil, resulting in illnesses and other health problems for your aquatic pets. Therefore, it is crucial to carefully prepare the soil before adding it to your aquarium to ensure a healthy and vibrant underwater environment for your fish.

High Maintenance

Soil is a substrate that requires more maintenance compared to gravel or sand. Over time, soil can become compacted, resulting in decreased nutrient and oxygen absorption. Regular aeration and cleaning of the soil are necessary to prevent the growth of harmful bacteria. Furthermore, as soil breaks down, organic matter and debris can accumulate in your aquarium, creating an unhealthy environment for your fish and causing water quality problems.

Difficulty in Plant Growth

If you’re thinking about using regular soil as a substrate in your aquarium, you may want to reconsider if live plants are part of your plans. This is because soil can be too compact and weighty, posing a challenge for aquatic plants to establish roots and flourish. Moreover, soil can quickly deplete the essential nutrients your plants need, leaving them vulnerable to nutrient deficiencies.

Regular Soil Vs Commercial Aquarium Soil

When considering using normal garden soil vs commercial aquarium soil as a substrate in your aquarium, it’s essential to understand the key differences between the two options. While both types of soil have their merits, they also come with distinct characteristics that can significantly impact the health of your aquatic ecosystem. Here’s a comparison of the two:

Aspect	Regular Soil	Commercial Aquarium Soil
Purpose	Used for outdoor and indoor terrestrial plants. It provides nutrients, retains moisture, and offers physical support for plant roots.	Designed for aquatic plants and aquarium setups. It promotes healthy root development in water, helps maintain water clarity, and can influence water parameters, like pH.
Composition	Contains a mixture of organic matter (decayed plants and animals), minerals, gases, and water. It might have sand, silt, and clay in varying proportions.	Often made from fired clay granules or certain types of volcanic soils. It may be enriched with nutrients beneficial for aquatic plants.
pH Level	The pH can vary widely depending on the type of soil and its components. Some soils are acidic, while others are alkaline.	Some types are designed to lower the pH and soften the water, making it more suitable for certain fish and plants that prefer such conditions.
Nutrient Content	Contains various essential nutrients required for plant growth, such as nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium. The nutrient content can vary based on the quality and type of soil.	Usually contains nutrients tailored for aquatic plants. Some substrates are nutrient-rich, while others require additional fertilization.
Water Retention	Designed to retain moisture but also allow for drainage to prevent root rot.	Does not retain water in the same way since it’s submerged, but it provides space for beneficial bacteria to colonize and promotes root health in an aquatic environment.
Aesthetics	Comes in a range of colors, usually brown, based on its organic and mineral content.	Often comes in darker shades (like black or dark brown) to create a natural-looking environment in the aquarium and highlight the colors of fish and plants.
Suitability	Suitable for a wide range of terrestrial plants.	Designed for freshwater planted aquariums. It may not be suitable for some fish species or saltwater tanks.
Price	Generally less expensive than specialized aquarium substrates.	Can be pricier due to its specialized nature and the processes involved in its creation.

How to Make Regular Soil Usable for Aquariums

Using regular garden soil in aquariums requires careful preparation to ensure that it’s suitable for aquatic life and doesn’t result in an unstable environment. Here’s a step-by-step guide to making regular soil usable for aquariums:

• Selection of Soil: Opt for organic, untreated garden soil. Avoid soils with added fertilizers, pesticides, or any other chemicals.
  
  
• Sifting and Cleaning: Sift the soil to remove any large particles, debris, sticks, or stones. Place the sifted soil in a large container and add water. Stir the mixture and allow the heavy particles to settle. Pour off the clear water and repeat this process several times until the water remains relatively clear.
  
  
• Sterilization: Sterilizing the soil can prevent unwanted organisms, pests, and pathogens from entering your aquarium. Spread the cleaned soil thinly on a baking tray and bake in an oven at 200°F (93°C) for 30-40 minutes. Alternatively, you can microwave moist soil for about 10 minutes, but be cautious as it can be messy.
  
  
• Layering in the Aquarium: Start with a thin layer (about 0.5 to 1 inch) of gravel or coarse sand at the bottom of the tank. This aids in drainage. Add a layer of the prepared soil (1 to 2 inches thick). Top the soil with a layer of fine aquarium sand or gravel (1 to 2 inches thick). This prevents the soil from mixing into the water column and causing cloudiness.
  
  
• Slow Filling: When adding water to the aquarium, do so very slowly to prevent disturbing the soil. Place a plate or bowl in the tank and pour water onto it to disperse the flow.
  
  
• Planting: Plant your aquatic plants immediately after filling. The roots will help stabilize the soil and prevent it from getting suspended in the water.
  
  
• Cycling: Before introducing fish, make sure to cycle the tank to establish beneficial bacteria. This can take several weeks. Monitor water parameters during this time.

Points to Consider:

• Gas pockets: Soil can produce gas pockets, especially in the initial stages. These pockets can contain harmful gases like hydrogen sulfide. To mitigate this, poke the soil layer with a stick during the first few weeks to release any trapped gases.
• Cloudiness: Even with careful preparation, the water might become cloudy initially. This should settle within a few days.
• Testing: Regularly test the water for ammonia, nitrites, nitrates, and pH to ensure the environment remains stable for your aquatic inhabitants.

Types of Regular Soils That Can Be Used in Aquarium

Regular soils can be a cost-effective and nutrient-rich substrate option for planted aquariums, but it’s crucial to choose the right type to ensure a stable and healthy environment for aquatic life. Here are types of regular soils that can be used in aquariums:

• Topsoil: This is the uppermost layer of soil and is usually rich in organic matter and nutrients. Ensure it’s free from added chemicals, fertilizers, and pesticides.
  
  
• Potting Soil: Some hobbyists have had success using potting soil. However, it’s essential to choose organic potting soil without added fertilizers, wetting agents, or other chemicals. Vermiculite and perlite, common in potting soils, can float in the water, so you might want to remove them or let them float up and skim them off during the preparation process.
  
  
• Loam Soil: This is a balanced blend of sand, silt, and clay. It’s often considered the best type of soil for gardening due to its optimal water retention and drainage capabilities. Loam is less likely to compact than clay-heavy soils, making it a good choice for aquariums as it allows for root penetration and reduces the risk of anaerobic pockets.
  
  
• Peat: While not a “soil” in the traditional sense, peat is an accumulation of decayed organic matter. It’s acidic and can be used in small amounts to soften water and lower pH. Due to its strong influence on water parameters, it should be used judiciously and in combination with other soils.

Things to Avoid:

• Soils with added fertilizers: These can release large amounts of ammonia into the water, which is toxic to fish.
• Soils with pesticides or herbicides: These can be harmful to aquatic life.
• Clay-heavy soils: While some clay is beneficial (and is the primary component in commercial “aquarium soil”), too much clay can compact and create anaerobic zones where harmful gases can accumulate.

Discover whether play sand can be a suitable choice for your aquarium substrate needs in our can you use play sand as aquarium substrate article. We delve into the pros and cons of using this readily available option, assessing its safety, maintenance requirements, and overall effectiveness in creating a thriving aquatic environment for your fish and plants.

Conclusion

Using regular soil as a substrate in your aquarium can be a natural and cost-effective option. However, caution must be exercised to ensure its safety and compatibility with aquatic life.

While regular soil is readily available and can provide essential nutrients to aquatic plants, it can also negatively impact water parameters, alter pH and hardness, and contain harmful impurities. Therefore, it is crucial to research the specific requirements of the plants and animals in your aquarium, as well as the composition of the soil, before using it as a substrate. Proper preparation and maintenance are necessary to ensure a healthy environment for your aquatic pets.

If you decide to use regular soil in your aquarium, make sure to prepare it correctly and monitor water parameters regularly to prevent issues with water quality and aquatic life. By following these tips, you can create a natural and visually stunning environment for your aquatic pets to thrive in.

Frequently Asked Questions